Singapore, 15 April 2020 – City Developments Limited (CDL) is well-positioned to deepen its China presence following a successful negotiation with Sincere Property Group (Sincere Property, or 协信远创), an established real estate developer in China.
Back in May 2019, CDL announced its intention to invest RMB 5.5 billion (approximately S$1.10 billion) comprising an equity investment and the extension of interest-bearing loans to acquire a 24% effective stake in Sincere Property1. The investment was to be split equally into two tranches, with the first tranche involving a four-year interest-bearing loan amounting to RMB 2.75 billion (approximately S$0.55 billion) to Sincere Property, part of which would be converted into equity, and the remaining tranche of RMB 2.75 billion to be invested upon fulfilling certain conditions. The transaction was expected to complete in Q4 2019 but due to a variety of factors, was not consummated. Hence, CDL did not acquire any equity interest in Sincere Property but had extended the initial tranche of RMB 2.75 billion as an interest-bearing loan in 2019.
Given the adverse impact of the COVID-19 crisis and the global uncertainty, CDL has taken the opportunity to negotiate new terms for its investment into Sincere Property, which are significantly improved over the original investment terms announced last year.
As of 15 April 2020, CDL has entered into a definitive agreement to acquire a 51.01% joint controlling interest in Sincere Property for an initial investment of RMB 4.39 billion (approximately S$0.88 billion2). Part of this investment quantum will be utilised to repay the RMB 2.75 billion loan extended by CDL to Sincere Property. Upon completion of the transaction, CDL will hold a joint controlling interest in Sincere Property via an offshore investment vehicle, making CDL the single largest shareholder of Sincere Property. Mr Wu Xu, Sincere Property’s Chairman and Founder, will see his stake reduce from 60% to 29% while Greenland Holdings Group Co., Ltd, a prominent developer in China, will see their shareholding in Sincere Property decrease from 40% to 19.99%.
As part of the transaction, a call option will also be granted to CDL to purchase an additional 9% effective interest in Sincere Property for RMB 0.77 billion (approximately S$0.16 billion2) at the same entry valuation. The call option will be exercisable at CDL’s discretion during a six-month period which will only commence upon either the expiry of 18 months from the completion of this transaction or 1 July 2022, whichever is later.
Assuming the call option is exercised, the total consideration to acquire a 60.01% effective stake in Sincere Property is RMB 5.16 billion (approximately S$1.04 billion2) as compared to the original deal consisting of RMB 5.5 billion (inclusive of interest-bearing loans) for a 24% effective stake. The new transaction is based on an agreed valuation of Sincere Property at RMB 8.60 billion vis-à-vis its net asset value (NAV) of RMB 16.48 billion as per Sincere Property’s unaudited consolidated financial statements for the year ended 31 December 2019 (FY 2019). This represents an attractive entry valuation of almost 50% below their NAV.